The cookie monsters of the world have long-debated the best flavor combinations — chocolate chip or oatmeal-raisin; peanut butter or cinnamon-sugar. But there's one fact that can unite us all: The bigger the cookie, the better. Here are eight oversize skillet cookies to prove it. Bake one up and serve celebratory slices at your next party, or just reinvent the cookie jar for an everyday snack.

Photography by Tara Donne